By SUZANNE DOWNING
Oct. 4, 2026 – Find someone who looks the part. Build the campaign around him. Sell the public an outsider while the professionals assemble the production backstage.
That’s the cynical political formula revealed remark attributed to Morris Katz, the media strategist and co-founder of the Fight Agency, whose consulting work has connections reaching into Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins’ campaign for Alaska governor.
Politico reported that Katz discussed the Graham Platner candidacy at a dinner in fashion designer Tory Burch’s Manhattan apartment.
According to one attendee, Katz described finding “a guy that looks like he’s a union working-class guy” and putting him forward. The account rests on that attendee’s recollection of a private conversation.
The operative words are “looks like.” That’s Bill Hill in Alaska’s congressional race. He looks the part.
Sullivan has the edge, but Alaska’s Senate race is now a turnout fight
Working-class voters, most of whom in Alaska are not members of any party, have become a marketing demographic. A candidate becomes the face selected to reach them. Democrat-aligned political consultants find the prospect, shape the presentation, and offer voters an apparently spontaneous uprising against the establishment.
Candidate in a box. Some assembly required.
Platner, the Maine oyster farmer recruited to challenge Republican Sen. Susan Collins, was supposed to demonstrate how well this formula could work. His advisers promoted his rugged appearance and outsider appeal. Then the campaign collapsed amid scandals, culminating in a sexual assault allegation that Platner denied. He withdrew in July. Politico’s subsequent reporting raised serious questions about the advisers’ vetting and their handling of warnings from campaign staff.
A compelling launch video and then a candidate face plant.
Alaskans should recognize the broader strategy. We have been watching versions of it for years.
In January 2018, Politico published “How to Turn a Red State Purple (Democrats Not Required).” Its account highlighted Kreiss-Tomkins, Forrest Dunbar, and John-Henry Heckendorn recruiting outsiders, persuading them to run, and supplying the campaign expertise and connections needed to win. They’ve been at this for years.
I wrote about that Democrat strategy at the time. The machinery included candidate recruitment, advertising, fundraising relationships, and coaching. The objective was to expand progressive power through candidates whose identities could reach beyond the traditional Democratic electorate.
Today, Kreiss-Tomkins’ own gubernatorial campaign has a financial connection to the very consultant network behind Platner and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
A review of campaign disclosures showed that Kreiss-Tomkins’ campaign paid Debra Schommer Media Group $165,725 and listed another $93,050 still owed to the company.
The Fight Agency was a subcontractor on expenditures involving Schommer and another consulting firm. Schommer handles substantial media work for Mamdani, whose successful mayoral campaign also used Fight Agency.
Morris Katz is an ad maker and strategist with Fight.
The same political consulting world that helped package Platner is doing business with the campaign of a man long associated with Alaska’s red-state-to-purple strategy.
Then there is Bill Hill. The ultimate candidate plucked out of thin air.
Hill’s candidacy is Alaska’s version of the Platner sales pitch: emphasize the working background, present a relatable outsider, and invite voters to see personal biography as proof of political independence.
On Sept. 15, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee added him to its “Red to Blue” program, even though he is an “undeclared” candidate. Its announcement emphasized his fishing, construction, and education background while promising organizational help, fundraising support, staff resources, training, and strategic guidance. The party’s congressional campaign arm is helping build the campaign of a candidate it repeatedly calls independent.
We’ve revealed here at The Alaska Story just how bad his education background is — he ran the Bristol Bay School District into the ground during his 10-year tenure.
Bill Hill ran Bristol Bay schools right into the ground; Naknek proficiency dropped to 5%
Voters deserve to weigh that Democrat Party backing alongside the independent label.
Recruiting candidates is usual, but the way Democrats are doing it is unusual Take Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, for example, entered the progressive recruitment pipeline after her brother nominated her. Organizers reviewed and vetted prospective candidates at a speed-dating type audition.
A fisherman like Bill Hill can have genuine experience on the water, but how does he arrive with an entire professional campaign apparatus suddenly behind him, and supplant the actual Democrat, Matt Schultz, who had am ample supply of baggage?
The voters should understand the stagecraft behind the scenes.
Katz’s remark offers a glimpse of how consultants discuss the candidates as a product: Find someone who looks convincing. Put forward someone straight out of central casting. That’s Bill Hill, Graham Platner, and even AOC.
Suzanne Downing is founder and editor of The Alaska Story and is a longtime Alaskan.





22 thoughts on “Suzanne Downing: Alaska’s candidate in a box? Bill Hill came straight out of Mamdani agency central casting”
Hillbilly Bill. A nobody from an area of Alaska that 95% of Alaskans don’t know anything about, nor do they care. A complete bafoon candidate on the same line as Decoy Dan. A Democrat spoof candidate with no creds whatsoever.👎👎
Ted, you nailed it to a tee.
You guys, I’m starting to think Trump isn’t going to give us:
• $2 gas
• No new wars
• Cheaper groceries
• A healthcare plan
• $5,000 DOGE checks
• $2,000 tariff checks
• 10% APR on credit cards
• Prices down “on day one”
• Prescriptions 60”% cheaper. What do you folks think about these “promises”?
It will take a whole lot of time to undo all the damage your hero’s Obama and Biden and their loyal American hating communist followers have done to this country. At least the borders have been sealed, and tens of thousands of illegal criminals have been deported. A lot more need to go. Massive amounts of fraud have been uncovered and billions in wasteful spending has been stopped. Thousands of lazy able-bodied freeloaders have been kicked off the welfare and Medicaid rolls. It’s a start, and much better than the alternative – the cackling and illiterate Kamala. Unlike you Demon, I won’t be satisfied until federal government spending is cut in half or less.
Disgraced former CNN anchor liberal Don Lemon disagrees with you, he recently admitted that President Trump has delivered on “pretty much every promise he made – pretty much, like, policy-wise – he has delivered”. Lemon continued “Like he said, ‘Look what I’m gonna do with immigration, I’m gonna do this with taxes, I’m gonna do this with healthcare,’ and he did all of them,”
No more illegals crossing the border works for me. ICE agents are heros. Biden was miserable, just like his loser, doper, criminal son.
My favorite “new war” was the river of Chinese fentanyl flowing into America using Venezuelan 600hp “fishing boats” that got vaporized and extinguished the supply chain quicker than you can say “Orange man bad”. 🙂
The AkGOP could take Acting lesson pointers from the Democrats. You can’t resent them doing their job to finding Actors. Politics is all Acting. Your future Republican candidates need to be also good storytelling like an Actor.
The best and most memorable Actors in politic is when he is a genuine and honest leader. They are the ones who become a political party’s legend, their time in office serving/acting moved the political party forward to greater control because of personality and integrity. The generations loved and trusted him during his lifetime serving. They are also team players always willing to let someone else shine because their success meant moving the party forward.
On one of Bill Hills advertisements the first line is that he’s a Native Alaskan, as if that is his most qualifying attribute. He says this while standing on a fishing boat that costs hundreds and hundreds of thousands of dollars and likely brings in hundreds of thousands of dollars in less than two months. Most Alaskans don’t own a boat that costs hundreds of thousands of dollars and brings in hundreds of thousands of dollars in revenue in less than two months.
He is used to catering to the 5% proficiency group around Naknek area who see that hundreds of thousands dollar boat as a badge of success and if they take his bait they will all have a boat just like the one he is “propped” on.
The Hillbilly is a phoney. Not a tough guy , like his ads appear. A p…y who ain’t getting my vote.
more Alaskans should be like Bill Hill. The opportunity is there for all Alaskans.
SteveO. Are you suggesting that an Alaska Native isn’t capable of owning such a boat ?
Evan,
How racist must you be to even imagine such a thing from what I wrote? Apparently extremely racist. Kinda funny, not haha funny, that people who see race in everything are always the racists. Bill Hill lists his being an Alaskan Native first and foremost in his advertising, that seems like a strange thing to me. If a white candidate started their advertisement by saying I’m white, wouldn’t you find that odd? What if a black candidate did the same, or a Jewish candidate?
Do you own a boat that costs hundreds and hundreds of thousands of dollars and likely brings in hundreds of thousands of dollars in less than two months? Do you imagine that as being racist to ask?
your comment was just stupid. Every candidate emphasizes their connection to Alaska. here is the first line from Begich’s site. Nick Begich was born in Anchorage and raised with the values that define Alaska. how about Wilson: Bernadette Wilson is a lifelong Alaskan, small business owner, mother of three, and a passionate advocate for the people and future of Alaska. Her roots run deep- from her grandmother born in the village of Naknek here is Bronson; After 30+ years in Alaska. If they were native they would be saying it. It is part of the Alaskan campaign. KInd of like wearing Copper River fleece. The boat you keep talking about is a 30 year old boat that Hill is the 5th owner of. Hardly something to get excited about in a fishery of million dollar boats. Apparently he owes a couple of hundred thousand on it because he repowered it. But I think he he sold it before this season so he probably paid off the loan. Maybe he recouped the cost of the repower. You seem to have an issue with his earnings. Like I mentioned before the opportunity is open to anyone. Steve you are probably one of those guys complaining about how the fisherman are all from outside. In my opinion Bill Hill is a good example of how Alaska fisheries should work. A local fisherman supporting his local economy. Not some carpetbagger taking his money south than paying state income tax on it because Alaskans doesn’t believe in taxes.
Speaking of stupid comments…is that you Bill? You seem to have a lot of information about things only Bill Hill would know, maybe you are just a very, very, very close associate. Do you think that being a Native Alaskan is his only or most qualifying attribute?
I don’t have a problem with anyone making an honest living, I certainly do have a problem with a socialist lying to the electorate about their own finances. The average Alaskan does not own a fishing boat that costs hundreds and hundreds of thousands of dollars and likely brings in hundreds of thousands of dollars in less than two months. Do you own a boat that costs hundreds of thousands of dollars and brings in hundreds of thousands of dollars in revenue in less than two months?
Leo,
In what settings have you ever heard anyone ever list their race first and foremost as their qualification for anything? Listing connections to Alaska has nothing to due with race based qualifications for elected office. You must run in an entirely different race (racist) based culture than I do.
steve you are fun to troll. You will never admit you are wrong. I never heard of Bill Hill until he decided to run for office. I am a retired commercial fisherman and didn’t like you attacking someone’s livelihood when you lack any understanding of the industry. The CFEC maintains a data base of all commercial vessels. Boats maintain the same ADFG number even when changing ownership. It is easy to track the history of a boat. The repower information I found in this article https://alaskabeacon.com/2026/10/06/alaskas-congressional-elections-pit-thousandaires-against-millionaires-and-billionaire-buddies/. No the average Alaskan doesn’t own a commercial fishing vessel worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. Why should they? But the average Bristol Bay fisherman does. Have you ever worked for a living or run in a business? You invest in the tools to make your business viable. How much do you think a mom and pop excavating company has invested in their business?
No I did not own a boat worth hundreds of thousands of dollars however if I had repowered it would have had that much into it. Lots of fisherman in the fishery I participated in did have that kind of money invested in their boats. I did not choose that path. As for making hundreds of thousands of dollars in two months. I would of loved to have. The fishery I was in really only offered the opportunity a couple of seasons in the time I participated. Price and volume need to coincide. It is great for Alaska that the opportunity exists.
I explained to you my opinion on the native issue. Every politician in Alaska likes to show their tie to Alaska. If they are native I have no issue with them saying it.
one more thing Steve. You are attacking a candidate for grossing a couple of hundred thousand dollars a year working and living and investing in his community. Yet you support the guy who has made millions out sourcing his work to India. What kind of a republican are you?
Leo,
I’ve also worked as a commercial fisherman and I did so in Bristol Bay, so it seems I know more about the specific subject than you…maybe next time instead of assuming that a person lacks any understanding of the subject you should just assume that you have no idea who you are talking to.
I never attacked anyone for “working and living and investing in his community” what I pointed out is that a candidate with socialist leanings and who wants to take other peoples money and redistribute it owns a boat that costs hundreds and hundreds of thousands of dollars and likely brings in hundreds of thousands of dollars in less than two months. It’s a typical candidate from the left nowadays, bourgeoisie socialist millionaires who think they know better and have more wealth than the proletariat they wish to rule over. Mamdani, El-Sayed, Plantner, Hill, Sand, etc., etc., etc. The left is full of wealthy socialists who pretend they aren’t wealthy…it’s weird.
Suzanne, your worldview is slight. I am an undeclared voter because I have lost confidence in all the parties. I am not a party person; I am a freedom person. I have to sift through the junkyard of propaganda and try to discern the motives, funders, backstory, and corporate investors that bias everything. Advocates, financed by NGOs?
How about this for a sound bite?
You all collectively have positive and negative things you do to add value; however, you are monetized by making my daily mental health, freedom, and quality of life worse.
I will tell you what seasons deteriorate my quality of life and my mental health.
The election season, which is getting longer and more damaging. Followed up right away by the health insurance sign-up season. I am exhausted. I am experiencing a multi-generational outlook that I did not foresee. I have small-business gold-miner parents that do not qualify for Medicaid or senior living. I have a 15-year-old daughter that I had at 40 years old. My first daughter, I gave birth to at 18 years old, despite her “dad” contesting.
I have dedicated my life to the decisions, naive or not, that I was a partner in. I have no regrets. But I will tell you right now I am tired. I already know where I stand.
Spoiler alert: nobody = these kids who are supposedly a target of indoctrination already has more life experience than the shit asses that are bombarding us with stupid ass messaging.
This is my call to action:
Shut the *****F***K up between now and the election.
I just really value my sleep and peace of mind.
[…] Suzanne Downing: Alaska’s candidate in a box? Bill Hill came straight out of Mamdani agency centra… […]