Sen. Robert Myers: Has the Permanent Fund turned Alaska government into a trust fund kid?

By SEN. ROBERT MYERS

Oct. 7, 2026 – The Permanent Fund Dividend came out last week at $1,200: $1,000 for the dividend and $200 for the “energy relief” payment.

Yet again, it was not the statutory amount, which should have been about $3800. It was also not the POMV 50/50 that the Legislature discussed moving to in 2021 as part of a full fiscal plan, which would have been $2964. It wasn’t even the POMV 25/75 plan that the Senate leadership assured us was sustainable just a couple of years ago, which would have been $1482 (before any energy relief payment).

As most long-time residents will remember, the PFD was first cut by Governor Walker in 2016. He said that we would need it soon to spend on government. After cutting the PFD in 2016 and 2017, the Legislature passed a plan to start using earnings from the Permanent Fund to pay for government using the POMV draw model in 2018. Over the last few years, not counting federal funds, the draw from the Permanent Fund has accounted for between 60-65% of the money used to pay for government. Oil has accounted for around another quarter of our revenue. The last 10-15% has come from other sources that haven’t changed much over the last couple of decades (fisheries taxes, non-oil corporate taxes, gas tax, cigarette tax, etc).

While it’s easy to sit there and do the math on how much money the state uses and where it comes from, the question that we haven’t asked in the last decade is a simple one. Was it a good idea to start using investment income as the primary revenue source for state government? It’s easy to talk about how cutting the PFD is the most regressive tax ever created. Or we can talk about how it pulls $1.5 to $1.8 billion from the state’s economy every year. Or we could talk about the damaging political effects when the people stop expecting the legislature to follow its own laws.

But aside from the dividend check itself, what we haven’t talked about is the political and economic effects of using passive investment income as the primary source for government revenue. I’ve talked about it in abstract terms in the past, referencing the incentives created by different revenue sources for government. Doing so separates public officials from the private economy where most of us live and work, a problem begun by using oil as our primary revenue source. But we need to talk about some concrete examples of how using the Permanent Fund for government spending has changed the political and economic landscape.

The point here is that spending Permanent Fund earnings has much broader implications than just an individual check. Even if the dividend didn’t exist, is it a good idea to use an investment account for government spending? What happens when we do? After ten years of cutting the dividend and eight years of spending it on government, where do we stand? I want to examine the effects of spending the Permanent Fund on government on three policies that we’ve been debating for the last few years: defined benefits, the gas line project, and education spending and policy.

As a quick reminder, Alaska switched its state employee retirement plan from a defined benefit (pension) plan in 2006 after changing demographics and some bad investments caused the previous plan to lose its fiscal stability. The Legislature instituted a defined contribution plan (401(k)-style plus annuity) instead. The state employee unions, and the Democratic Party in general, have been pushing to go back to a defined benefits plan ever since. The DB plan was included in various bills and floor amendments every year since the switch was made, but it gained no serious traction until 2021. That was the first year that a defined benefits system passed a body (the House) of the state legislature. The Senate passed a version in 2024, and both bodies passed a version this year, which was vetoed by the governor.

So what changed? We started spending the Permanent Fund on government. We figured out over the last forty years that oil is a highly unstable revenue source, completely unsuitable for an inflexible and growing expense like a pension plan. But investment earnings are much more stable (although not as stable as some other income streams) and large enough to fund the system. Using the Permanent Fund was the key to providing the funding source needed to make a return to a pension plan look viable. The interesting part is that we have some legislators who are fine with cutting the dividend and using the Permanent Fund for government but are against the defined benefits plan. They don’t seem to realize that they are enabling the very thing that they oppose.

The availability of the Permanent Fund for government also affected the gas line debate. The debates this past year over it were highly illuminating.

Most people in the state look at the gas line as either a source of energy that would finally provide some relief from high prices once exports started or as an economic driver from building and running the system or the other industries that having a large source of natural gas could unlock. But some in the legislature look at the project very differently. They want to know how much we could extract from it through taxes. Or they want to know how much building it would cost the state in terms of extra police, kids in school, etc. There is nothing wrong with these questions, and we should get a handle on those answers, but, interestingly, those became the overriding concerns rather than the economic impact of the project, either during construction or after completion.

But we should have expected that. The legislature already has a stable source of revenue in the Permanent Fund that is not connected to the state’s economy. Increased economic activity in general leads to higher state spending. It means more road maintenance, more kids in school (if workers move here permanently), and more public safety spending for when people do stupid things on Friday night.

Most states accept this tradeoff because the increased activity also means more tax revenue to pay for it all. But that’s not true for us because we don’t have a broad-based tax to collect revenue from general economic activity. That makes our legislature much more skeptical of economic activity. The only revenue we get from the gas line is what tax the line directly or what we get from selling the gas.

For example, if the new gas source allowed us to reopen the fertilizer plant in Nikiski instead of just exporting the gas, the state wouldn’t get anything from it even though it could employ lots of people and be an economic driver for years to come. But the Kenai Peninsula Borough would get property tax revenue from the plant and the workers’ homes and sales tax revenue from the workers’ salaries being spent in the area. Not surprisingly, they want the line to be built and the plant to reopen. The legislature doesn’t appear to be as enthusiastic.

To be sure, we can’t know the motives of every individual legislator, and there were a lot of other factors at play during this last session: animosity between the governor and the legislature, skepticism of the project economics, an interest in converting to wind and solar energy instead of natural gas, etc. But we know that having a revenue source completely disconnected from the state’s economy played a part because there were comments made about it, especially in the Senate. There were comments about not getting enough money from the project, lots of costs to the state, and concern that costs would come in before revenue would arrive.

In short, having the Permanent Fund available to spend was not the only factor in letting the legislature refuse to create a stable tax structure to allow the project to get financing. But the Permanent Fund gave the state the financial freedom it needed in order to say no. The state has a stable revenue source in the Permanent Fund, and it is not anxious for more, especially if it comes with uncertain costs. The problem is that the revenue source does not change in proportion to economic activity or population, giving the state an incentive to fight against economic and population growth.

If the state doesn’t want a stronger economy, how does it feel about some of the factors that could get us to one? We’ve had a lot of debate over the last few years over education funding, and, when the incentives are aligned, a quality education system that creates good results is a strong contributor to a growing economy. Simply put, educated workers are more productive.

But our incentives are not aligned properly, mostly because of how our government is funded. The debate over the last few years has largely aligned between those who want to fund a system and those who want to educate kids; in other words, the debate is between inputs and results. But here is the big question that we haven’t asked: does the state have an incentive to have an educated population and care about results in the first place?

Most state governments want a quality education because an educated population, in general, leads to a stronger economy, which leads to more tax revenue. But Alaska doesn’t have that. We have largely disconnected economic activity from tax revenue. The state has an incentive to want less economic activity, not more. Why would the state want kids to actually get educated if the state doesn’t see a benefit from it?

What do politicians want to see? They want to look like they care because that gets them reelected. So they will fight for more education spending because spending appears to equate to caring, but it does not necessarily equate to results. Education is no longer an investment with a big payout far into the future but an expenditure on conspicuous consumption.

For some jobs, such as medicine or engineering, we definitely need some highly educated people. But growing those professions organically means that we have to spend a lot of effort through both money and policy to educate the whole population. After all, we don’t know when kids are in elementary school which ones will be our future doctors or drilling engineers.

We’re used to importing people from Outside anyway, so it’s much easier from the state’s perspective to continue to do that rather than spending the effort to create the right policies and environment to actually create a well-educated population. Since educating the population as a whole won’t benefit the state in terms of tax revenue in the long run anyway, why bother? A well-funded system that produces poor results but creates loyal voters is the logical result.

The simple fact is that the debate from 2016 to 2018 over spending the Permanent Fund on government was too shallow. We talked about comments made at the creation of the Permanent Fund. We talked about how the state could get more money at the least political cost. But we didn’t talk about how different revenue models would give the state different incentives for behavior later on. We all expect that a 20-something who works for a living will behave differently than a 20-something who makes his money from a trust fund, even if their income is the same in dollar figures.

Why haven’t we applied that same principle to government? We need to come to terms with that principle if we want to turn our economy around and give people enough hope for the long term to reverse our working-age out-migration.

Senator Robert Myers was born in Fairbanks and spent much of his young childhood at the Salchaket Roadhouse, owned by his parents. He attended the University of Alaska Fairbanks, where he studied philosophy, political science, and history. While in college, he drove for a tour company, sharing  Alaska with countless visitors. He currently drives truck and travels the Dalton Highway (Haul Road) frequently. He ran for office because he wants an Alaska his children will choose to make their home down the road. When not working for his Senate District B, North Pole, he enjoys reading, history, board games, and spending time with his wife Dawna and his five kids.

 

Latest Post

Comments

11 thoughts on “Sen. Robert Myers: Has the Permanent Fund turned Alaska government into a trust fund kid?”
  1. If JKT gets elected governor, there will be LOTS of out-migration, sir. Reasonable, conservative Alaskans don’t want to be governed by a homosexual man who lives with his parents in Sitka. He has no prior work experience except being in the Alaska Legislature. His fishing ads are a bunch of BS. He’s a sissyboy. Hey, you worked with him in Juneau. Tell us who he really is…..

    1. That’s the right question Sarge, who is he? Why so little information about his past , and why is he being given a pass on personal bio? Is he a family man or friends with benefits guy. Who does he rub shoulders with? Ever been married to a man or woman, and can he define each? Does he own a house in Alaska and live in it? Is he a member of Oath Keepers, or the SDA?
      We know his policy statements echo stupid unlimited, and party obedience is #1. Just askin…..

      1. So, Senator Myers, who is JKT? Didn’t you work with him in the Alaska Legislature for five or six years? As a contributor to Alaska Story, tell us about JKT.

        1. Agree. I want to hear what Mr. Myers has to say about JK too. Since Mr. Myers is leaving politics it wouldn’t hurt him politically to tell us about JKT. That is, unless Mr. Myers is afraid of him in case JKT becomes governor.

        2. This thread is the epitome of a talking points campaign. A bunch of people show up to pile on comments carrying the exact same message. In the process, they validate the concern that lack of access to information was not the historical cause of ignorance. Addressing the simple part first, the legislative tenures of JKT and Robb Myers overlapped for two years, not “five or six years”. As for the rest, do you realize I no longer live in Alaska? I access my information over the net, just the same as you could have. JKT is registered to vote in Anchorage at an address in College Village. Two interesting things came about from learning this. The house is directly next door to the longtime residence of Arliss Sturgulewski. The property owner listed in MOA records at that address spent eight years as an aide to Sen. Sullivan, and prior to that was an aide to Gov. Parnell. Since there’s so much denial and suppression when people discuss the Uniparty, I’ll just leave it there. I already addressed the matter of his family, once again based on information I found online.

    2. Just the Republicans and conservative voters who can Afford to relocate and move out of Alaska. There would be a lot of good and simple minded folks on the Right who are loyal supporters to the AKRepublican Party governance model and supportive to Trump who will be left at the mercy of the AKDemocrats, while stronger Republican community leaders because of wealth they had the ability to leave the group abandoning a ship during a storm leaving lower-class crewman and passengers behind to fend for themselves.

  2. I predict more Alaskans and new arrivals will move on upon seeing the mess Alaska’s Corrupt Bastards club manipulated. people today are more concerned about their comfort than roll up their sleeves and work hard moving Alaska Right, since 2020 the Alaska Right and moderate center neighbors had SIX YEARS to turn their community councils toward Right. But the group haven’t even started the work and COVID is long behind us and the 2026, the right are still fighting like they are fighting over mask mandates, business and church lockdowns, and Covid jab ids.
    Mister Meyer (fmr State Senator) yours and your Interior Republican groups members fight is taking back control over your region’s local governance.

    1. Every time we see an advance of Democrats taking new territory like controlling not only the court, the legislature, but also finally the executive branch, it’ll always reveal who were the Weak Republican neighbors and community leaders leaving for Redder districts what they think are Republican strongholds.
      We saw it in once Anchorage Republicans moved north into the Interior and Matsu or South into Kenai peninsula or out of state, I remember watching on Facebook fmr residents touting their “wise” decision to leave Anchorage decades ago while Anchorage was going through Berkowitz business and church lockdowns. However the madness they thought they escaped is Increasingly spreading from Fairbanks to Matsu and down to the Kenai like a wildfire. Because those who retreat during battle don’t know how to fight.

  3. Senator Myers long piece above forgets one important point.
    The P- Fund had one purpose.
    To limit the growth of Government by taking 25% of the Oil plunder out of the hands of the political parasites.
    The funds creator, Oral Freeman made that point perfectly clear.
    None of the fund or of its earnings were ever supposed to be used to fund Government.
    What you see today is theft of a fund created for the people.
    Politicians can raise revenue via taxation. The Legislature has the power to tax. Problem is… wealthy people will pay the tax in a greater portion, while most Alaskans will not be subject to a tax.
    Wealthy people have access to the political parasites and can manipulate their actions.
    Prove me wrong.

  4. Senator Myers, your “trust fund kid” comparison raises a necessary question, but the deeper issue is who controls Alaska’s wealth—and who answers to its owners.
    In the Commonwealth Canada interview premiered on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hoGMwNuDTN4 , Rick Halford warned that the political process “over represents the present and under represents the future” (about 7:42–7:55). He also described the dividend’s connection to Fund performance as protection against unwise management and competing appropriations (about 37:49–39:44).
    That connection matters. When citizens receive a dividend tied to investment performance, they have a direct reason to watch the Fund. When politicians determine the dividend through annual bargaining, citizens’ share becomes another concession demanded to preserve somebody else’s appropriation.
    Dr. Jack Hickel described seeing “poor people living on Rich lands” (about 6:01–6:14). Alaska should take that warning seriously. A growing investment account means little to a family priced out of heat, housing, transportation, and opportunity.
    I have acted on that concern. Since February, I have advanced a proposal to evaluate reallocating $10 billion of Permanent Fund investments into Alaska general obligation bonds supporting productive infrastructure. I renewed that request for the trustees’ annual meeting in Nome after receiving no substantive response to my spring presentation.
    The purpose is to earn a return while building the roads, energy systems, and access that could strengthen Alaska’s private economy. The proposed 7–7.5% interest rate must be tested against repayment capacity, market conditions, investment risk, and the Fund’s fiduciary duties. The people deserve a serious public evaluation, with independent accounting and measurable results.
    Halford’s interview also challenges my proposal. Around 26:32–27:12, he warns that infrastructure arguments can conceal private advantage. Fair enough! Every proposed project should disclose who benefits, who owns adjoining interests, who receives contracts, and who bears the risk. Public investment must withstand that examination.
    That is precisely why my investment proposal accompanies my longstanding demands for accountability: compliance with applicable bonding laws, disclosure of conflicts, faithful performance of public duties, and independent review when officials’ own conduct is questioned. Those demands include Permanent Fund trustees. A trustee’s title does not place that official above the law. Removing a bonding provision from a bylaw cannot, by itself, extinguish an obligation imposed by statute.
    To the commenter arguing that Fund earnings were never available for government: Article IX, Section 15 distinguishes protected principal from income available as provided by law. Our strongest argument rests on accurate constitutional language, fair treatment of citizens, and enforceable accountability.
    And the comments drifting into personal attacks on a gubernatorial candidate do not answer Senator Myers’s fiscal argument. Examine candidates’ records, decisions, and duties. Alaska’s future deserves that seriousness.
    Senator, will you help secure a public examination of this investment proposal and the accountability questions surrounding our Fund?
    Article I, Section 2 places political power in the people. Our public servants owe us answers.
    Liberty Ed Martin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *