Federal judge blocks DOJ’s gun-rights lawsuit against Maryland county gun restrictions

THE ALASKA STORY

Nov. 15, 2026 – The Trump administration’s challenge of restrictive state and local gun laws has encountered an Obama-appointed  federal judge who says the Justice Department cannot use a police-misconduct statute simply because it believes a county gun law violates the Second Amendment.

The Nov. 9 dismissal of the department’s lawsuit against Montgomery County, Maryland, raises questions about a legal strategy being used to defend gun owners’ rights.

For Alaskans, the broader issue is how much authority Washington has to intervene when state or local governments restrict those rights.

Such instances are rare in Alaska, but do occur. For example, in 2025, East Anchorage Assembly Member Karen Bronga introduced two firearm-related ordinances. One would have expanded liability so parents or guardians could be prosecuted as principals (class A misdemeanor) if a minor brought a deadly weapon (including a firearm) to school grounds or a school function, and the parent/guardian had provided the weapon or stored it in a “criminally negligent” manner.  Another would have required anyone who owns or possesses a firearm to report its loss or theft to law enforcement (with a description/serial number if known) within 48 hours of discovery, or face a class B misdemeanor.

US District Judge Theodore D. Chuang, who was appointed by President Barack Obama in 2014, dismissed the case without deciding whether the county’s gun restrictions violate the Second Amendment.

The Justice Department sued in August over a local ordinance restricting firearms at numerous locations and within 100 yards of them. The department argued the exclusion zones make ordinary, lawful public carry practically impossible, even for people with carry licenses.

The dispute turns on 34 U.S.C. § 12601, a federal law authorizing the Justice Department to pursue patterns or practices of unconstitutional conduct by law enforcement.

The Justice Department argued that the county’s adoption of the restrictions, combined with the expectation that police would enforce them, supplied grounds for federal intervention.

Chuang decided the complaint identified no actual enforcement of the challenged restrictions and the ordinance did not specifically direct officers to engage in unconstitutional conduct. In his reading,

The administration faces two separate questions: whether a gun restriction violates the Constitution, and whether the Justice Department has statutory authority to bring that particular lawsuit.

A similar warning emerged in California, where US District Judge Monica Ramirez Almadani, who was a President Joe Biden appointee, denied the Justice Department’s request for a preliminary injunction against the state’s “Glock ban” in July. That preliminary ruling did not dispose of the entire case, but it questioned the same use of the police-misconduct statute.

Alaska’s Constitution expressly protects an individual right to keep and bear arms against infringement by the state or its political subdivisions. That state protection provides a separate constitutional basis for scrutinizing restrictions adopted here.

The Administration has continued pursuing gun-rights cases. On Nov. 9, the same day as the Maryland dismissal, the Justice Department announced a separate lawsuit challenging Glendale, California’s concealed-carry permitting fees and procedures.

Latest Post

Comments

2 thoughts on “Federal judge blocks DOJ’s gun-rights lawsuit against Maryland county gun restrictions”
  1. > Theodore D. Chuang

    The consequences of giving power to wrong culture, wrong religion.

    The Hart-Caller Act of 1965 continues to damage our country.

    The culture of our country is Native American, European and West African. This is a Christian country. We must have the courage to defend what our ancestors gave us. It’s pretty amazing and worth defending- as is our children and grand children. Never allow others to denigrate your culture or faith. We need to stop foreigners from having any power over us.

    1. Micah, you know as well as anyone else here that self-loathing radical leftists hate their culture, hate their country, and most of all hate themselves. That is why they are a die-hard suicide cult, not just individually but on a cultural and a societal level. They seek destruction and chaos at every opportunity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *