Win Gruening: Keep Alaska’s presidential vote Alaska’s

By WIN GRUENING

Nov. 20, 2026 – Should Alaska’s electoral votes go to a presidential candidate Alaska voters rejected? That is the issue behind the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, a proposal that would make the nationwide popular vote, not the outcome within each participating state, determine where each state’s electoral votes go.

The plan to effectively dismantle the Electoral College would have far-reaching consequences. The Electoral College is comprised of 538 electors. That number is based on the 435 members of the US House of Representatives plus the 100 senators from our 50 states and three electors from the District of Columbia. Alaska is one of a handful of states that have only three electors. California has 54.

Although the U.S. Constitution allows states to determine how to award their electoral votes, most states have awarded their full slate of electors to the candidate who receives the most votes in that state. But the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC) project, an effort led largely by the Left to bypass the Electoral College, would  elect the president through a national popular vote.

How JKT’s win puts Alaska in play in the push to bypass the Electoral College

This is not an effort to amend the Constitution by totally abolishing the Electoral College, which would be enormously difficult. Instead, what the NPVIC seeks is an agreement or “compact” among the states, in which all the electoral votes of the participating states would be cast for the winner of the national popular vote, regardless of who actually wins the electoral votes in their state.

For example, hypothetically, if Pennsylvania were in the compact and Gavin Newsom, a Democrat, won the most popular votes in the national election, all of Pennsylvania’s electoral votes (19) would be cast for Newsom, even if his Republican opponent had actually won the popular vote in Pennsylvania.

As of November 2026, 18 states and Washington, D.C., had adopted legislation to join the NPVIC. Together, they represent 222 Electoral College votes, 48 short of the 270 votes needed to elect a president and for the agreement to go into effect. It would only take a handful of states that command enough electoral votes and the necessary support in their state legislature to push this over the top.

The real danger in tinkering with the  Electoral College isn’t that a future president wouldn’t receive the most popular votes but that he or she wouldn’t be representative of the country at all.

Without the Electoral College in its current form, it’s possible to envision a scenario where a third-party candidate wins a presidential election with less than 40% of the popular vote – mostly from a handful of large states but lacks geographic representation across the country. What our existing Electoral College provides is assurance that whoever is elected is supported by a diverse cross-section of the country, not just a few populous states – like California or New York.

States like Alaska with small populations still wield influence through their exercise of 3 electoral votes. This is only 7 votes fewer than Wisconsin and 8 votes fewer than Arizona, states with much larger populations. Alaska, and other states not in the compact, would be mostly irrelevant if NPVIC is enacted.

A nationwide vote tally also deserves scrutiny and consistency as an administrative system. If the national margin were exceptionally close, how would recounts, disputed ballots, and differing state procedures be handled? Before changing the practical rules for electing a president, voters deserve clear answers.

NPVIC is a back-door way of circumventing the Constitution which will introduce a whole host of unintended consequences. The compact would leave the Electoral College nominally intact while fundamentally changing how it operates. A change of that magnitude deserves the broad public consent associated with constitutional reform, not merely enough state legislation to trigger an interstate agreement.

No electoral system is perfect, and the Electoral College is no exception. But replacing state-by-state outcomes with a nationwide tally is not a minor procedural adjustment. It changes what presidential candidates must win, and what a state’s voters can decide.

Before Alaska surrenders that distinction, advocates of change should make a much stronger case. Until that happens, there is no reason to change the system our Founding Fathers envisioned that has worked for hundreds of years.

Win Gruening retired as senior vice president in charge of business banking for Key Bank for the State of Alaska in 2012. He was born and raised in Juneau and graduated from the US Air Force Academy in 1970. After serving as a pilot in the US Air Force flying in the Pacific and Vietnam, Win began his banking career with Rainier Bank in Seattle and moved home  to Juneau in 1980. Win has been involved extensively in various local and statewide organizations such as United Way, Junior Achievement, and the Alaska Committee.

Latest Post

Comments

3 thoughts on “Win Gruening: Keep Alaska’s presidential vote Alaska’s”
  1. This is a rational argument against the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. The author doesn’t argue it would be illegal, he argues it would not be a good idea for Alaska. I disagree, I think it would be good for the nation, which includes Alaska. The proposal would better ensure that the American people elect the President and Vice President, that it’s not done by some obscure group of ill-apportioned politico weirdos. As for the author’s fear that the President might come from a populous state, may I remind this site’s readers that, under the current system, Reagan and Nixon were from California, Johnson and both Bushes were from Texas, and Trump’s from New York/Florida. Going to need a better argument than “The President might come from a populous state.”

  2. Only a fool would want Alaska to give up its electoral college votes. It is about as anti-Alaskan as you can get. No matter how you want to paint it.
    The 3 electoral votes are the only weight Alaska has in a Presidential election. If we did not have our precious 3 votes, Then there would no longer be any reason to vote for President in Alaska. The founders of our country were correct when they established the Electoral College then and now.
    It will be interesting to see the position of Uber leftist Tomkins assumes. Side bar….I refuse to call the Governor by anything but his last name like all Alaskan Governors before Baldy.

    1. No one is asking Alaska to give up its electoral college votes. It’s 3 now, it’ll remain 3. And our votes will be just as loud as any other votes in the US. No more swing states! All votes equal! And no more presidents hobbled by knowing they came in second.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *