Proud Mary: Court rules House vote Peltola took on a $1.7 trillion spending bill was unconstitutional

By SUZANNE DOWNING

Nov. 21, 2026 – Back in 2022, Mary Peltola showed up in person to vote for the $1.7 trillion federal spending bill just before Christmas.

A federal appeals court has now ruled that too few of her colleagues showed up for the House to have a constitutional quorum.

In a 9–8 en banc decision in Texas v. Blanche, the Fifth US Circuit Court of Appeals held that the House violated the Constitution’s Quorum Clause by counting absent members as present through proxies.

The speaker at the time was Nancy Pelosi and Democrats were in charge of the House.

The ruling upheld an injunction blocking federal enforcement of one provision of the spending law, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, against the State of Texas as an employer. The rest of the spending package was outside the scope of that injunction.

The House approved the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 on Dec. 23, 2022, by a vote of 225–201, with one member recorded as present and four not voting. The court said 226 members recorded their presence and votes by proxy, leaving fewer than a majority physically present. The House clerk lists Peltola as a “Yea,” and she voted in person.

Peltola said in a Facebook post that day that she had “proudly voted for” the bill, citing its support for working families and investment in Alaska communities. The package included nearly $500 million in Alaska earmarks requested by Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski, who voted for it in the Senate.

Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan voted against the bill in the Senate, citing the compressed timetable for reviewing the more than 4,000-page package.

Peltola’s House attendance later drew scrutiny. GovTrack shows show she missed 235 of 1,370 roll-call votes during her time in Congress, or about 17%. On this vote, she was among the lawmakers who came to the chamber.

Texas Republican Rep. Chip Roy raised the quorum issue on the House floor that day. He asked how the House could have a quorum when 226 members had voted by proxy. Rep. G.K. Butterfield, the Democrat presiding over the chamber, told him that members voting or recording their presence by proxy counted under the House’s pandemic-era rules.

Writing for the majority, Judge Cory Wilson said the Constitution requires a majority to be physically present for the House to conduct business.

The court addressed whether proxies could establish a quorum, leaving open whether lawmakers could vote by proxy once an in-person quorum had been established. Judge James Graves, joined by six judges, argued in dissent that the Constitution gives the House broad latitude to set its own procedures, and that the Quorum Clause does not categorically require physical presence.

Latest Post

Comments

3 thoughts on “Proud Mary: Court rules House vote Peltola took on a $1.7 trillion spending bill was unconstitutional”
  1. Lie. The court did not rule that Senator-Elect Peltola’s vote was unconstitutional. But grats on finding the most unflattering photo of her you could, I know that’s a big focus in right-wing-enragment-blogs like this one.

    1. Direct quote from the decision “We further conclude that the Act’s passage was unconstitutional because the Quorum Clause does not allow proxies to be included when establishing a quorum.” Peltola vote “yea” ipso facto her vote was unconstitutional.

      1. Ridiculous, disingenuous distortion of the court’s opinion. The court held that the bill’s passage was unconstitutional, not that voting on it was unconstitutional. Peltola was present, a vote was called, she voted. 426 people voted on this thing. Are you saying that everyone who voted against the bill also cast an unconstitutional vote, because there was no quorum? Or just the people who voted in favor? Either way you look really silly. Looking forward to six years of this kind of pretend outrage here at TheAlaskaStory.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *