By SUZANNE DOWNING
Nov. 18, 2026 — The US Justice Department has issued more than 200 subpoenas in its criminal investigation into the candidacy of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., the retired Petersburg teacher who ran against Republican U.S. Sen. Dan S. Sullivan on Alaska’s November ballot, Fox News Digital reported Wednesday.
Fox cited a law enforcement source who said the investigation spans several states, involves multiple targets and will continue following Democrat Mary Peltola’s victory. A second source familiar with the investigation confirmed the subpoena count to Fox.
The Associated Press called the race for Peltola on Tuesday evening, two weeks after Election Day. Peltola received 144,302 votes to the incumbent’s 131,844, a margin of 12,458. Republican Gerald Heikes received 6,105 votes, and the second Sullivan, Decoy Dan who is now missing, received 4,760.
Peltola crossed 50% of first-choice votes in Tuesday’s count, giving her an outright majority without ranked-choice transfers.
The investigation centers on allegations that Democratic operatives sought out another candidate named Dan Sullivan to confuse voters and draw support away from the Republican incumbent. Days before the election, The New York Times reported that Peltola campaign aides, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee and operatives outside Alaska were involved in an effort they called the “ballot composition project.” Peltola dismissed the report as a distraction, and Daniel Sullivan denied wrongdoing.
Democratic election lawyer Marc Elias, whose firm represents Peltola’s campaign, received a criminal target letter earlier this month. A target letter alerts a recipient that prosecutors consider that person a target of an investigation. It does not constitute a criminal charge.
Where is ‘Decoy Dan’? Election ends, and he is still nowhere to be found
As The Alaska Story reported Oct. 30, Alaska US Attorney Michael Heyman said investigators had been working on the case for months before the Times report prompted federal authorities to send additional law enforcement resources to Alaska. At the time, Heyman declined to identify any targets or say which criminal statutes prosecutors were examining.
The two Sullivans had been the subject of a ballot fight since June, when the Alaska Division of Elections disqualified the Petersburg candidate. An Anchorage Superior Court judge reinstated him, and the Alaska Supreme Court allowed him to stay on the ballot. In October, the Justice Department brought a separate civil case over possible voter confusion. US District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed that suit Nov. 1, and the department appealed.
The 4,760 votes cast for the second Sullivan were fewer than Peltola’s margin over the incumbent. Fox’s law enforcement source said the election result does not change the criminal investigation.





One thought on “Fox News: DOJ has issued more than 200 subpoenas in Alaska’s ‘Decoy Dan’ probe”
Nancy and I are dreading these subpoenas. We had Mary over to our Wrangell safe haven last summer, multiple times. She was passing through with Lisa during one of her several visits to Petersburg. Lisa introduced us.
We should qualify for diplomatic immunity. We only served tea and cookies and never, ever discussed the Decoy plot. Although, Lisa had knowledge and told us to just be quiet and play like old folks with dementia. And we weren’t playing.