By JEREMIAH WILLIAMS
Oct. 7, 2026 – The last thing a hunter needs to pack before a moose hunt is a crash course in federal regulations and bureaucracy. We shouldn’t need to spend the days before a hunt refreshing federal websites, comparing land-status maps, deciphering emergency actions, and trying to determine whether our regular hunting spot is suddenly subject to a different set of rules. But apparently, thanks to the feds, that’s where we are now.
On Sept. 3, actively in moose hunting season, the Federal Subsistence Board approved Emergency Wildlife Special Action Request WSA26-09 by email, closing specified federal public lands in Unit 25D to moose hunting by non-federally qualified hunters from Sept. 10-20.
That’s right. A federal board made a consequential decision about who could hunt public land, and did so via an email string completely out of public view. There was no Zoom meeting to tune into. No teleconference where hunters could listen to Board members deliberate. No public meeting where Alaskans could hear, in real time, how each member justified their decision.
Instead, the vote happened in their inboxes. The Board’s rules may allow that. But “allowed” and “ideal” are two very different things. When a decision about who can hunt public land is made by email just days before the closure takes effect, Alaskans deserve to see how that decision was made and hear the reasoning behind it.
Decisions that shut hunters out of public lands should be made in public In fact, the Board’s own meeting guidelines call an open public meeting the “preferred forum” for emergency special actions. So why wasn’t there one? Why couldn’t the Board get on a public Zoom or teleconference and let Alaskans watch their government make the decision? How were the votes collected and verified? What safeguards surrounded the vote? Was there discussion among Board members before or while they voted?
If the answer is simply, “The rules allow us to do it by email,” that’s not good enough. Transparency isn’t a technicality. It matters most when the government is exercising its power to tell people that public land they expected to hunt is suddenly off-limits.
Here’s what makes this even more infuriating: this wasn’t some unforeseen wildlife emergency that suddenly appeared in September. The underlying decision was made in April through Wildlife Proposal WP26-75. The feds had months to address this. But because the federal regulatory process wasn’t completed in time, hunters received an emergency action just as moose season was arriving. Their delay became a hunter’s emergency. Moose season didn’t sneak up on anyone. September is on the calendar every year, last time we checked.
And after the last-minute decision came the next problem: figuring out what it actually meant in real life. In Unit 25D, WSA26-09 applies to specified federal public lands along major river corridors. But navigable waters present an entirely different jurisdictional question. Dependingon land status and navigability, state-managed hunting opportunities may remain below the
Ordinary High Water Mark while the federal uplands immediately beside it are closed. Got all that? You’d better. Because while the government makes the rules confusing, the government doesn’t pay the price when you misunderstand them. You do.
On Sept. 16, the Board considered Emergency Wildlife Special Action Request WSA26-12, seeking to implement yet another April decision, Wildlife Proposal WP26-31, changing moose hunting on our public lands in Unit 13. Again, the vote happened by email.
This time, however, the Board rejected the request because it arrived too late. Hunters were already in the field, and implementing the closure at that point could create “confusion and conflict.” You think?
That’s exactly the problem. Hunters shouldn’t find out that the rules are shifting while we’re packing camp, driving to the trailhead, running upriver, or already sitting in hunting camp. Government decisions about who gets to hunt federal public lands shouldn’t disappear into an email inbox where the people affected can’t watch the deliberation happen.
Hunters have responsibilities. We must know the regulations and whose land we’re on. We must, and should, respect private property, understand boundaries, and follow the law. The feds have responsibilities, too. Finish the regulatory process on time and give hunters adequate notice. Make the rules understandable to a normal person and show us exactly what’s open and what’s closed. And if you’re going to vote to remove hunting access, do it in the open where the people losing that access can watch it happen.
It’s not an unreasonable ask. It’s the bare minimum. Alaska hunters shouldn’t need a law degree, or a sneak peek into a federal official’s inbox, to know where they can hunt moose.
Jeremiah Williams is president of Safari Club International Alaska Chapter.





6 thoughts on “Jeremiah Williams: You shouldn’t need a law degree to hunt moose in Alaska”
You must be really young. We’ve been fighting this for 46 years since the subsistence morass was delivered with ANILCA. It’s a done deal, and it gets worse with hunting pressure and cyclical game population swings.
Welcome to The Machine.
Bingo. I remember attending numerous Federal Subsistence Board meetings in Ninilchik back in the mid-90’s and the divide and conquer mentality that theater of tools delivered to the Kenai. One side of an arbitrary line and you were federally chosen. The other side of the line meant you were a second class citizen. Divide and conquer. Back then I was singled out for a private hallway huddle by upper management types over “making such a fuss over a few fish for a few locals”. Liars and charlatans. You can study history or you can trust government, but you can’t do both.
In every state in this nation the states have the primary authority over the fish and game within their borders, except in Alaska. When the feds can drop fish and game closures on a whim in areas the size of entire states, that is federal overreach that should not be tolerated.
Thanks Jimmy Carter! Just another part of your terrible legacy.
The (then) governor and our delegation did not fight hard enough to keep lands for the state and now federal bureaucrats tell us what we are allowed to do with our own resources. Utterly shameful.
A few years back I had a ” local” or resident tag for moose up in the North West portion of our State. ( read any bull) I planned on a fly out hunt. Suddenly the air service began to question the validity of my tag.
Turns out the Feds had a caveat regarding fly out hunts on Federal land. I contacted the Federal representative regarding my situation. Apparently one could access Federal land via boat or ATV only. I protested, I explained that unlike many other ” local” hunters I could not afford a 6 figure $ Skiff, and that the flyout option was a fraction of the cost of owning a 125K boat.
Guess what happened? I hunted on State land!
Despite the ridiculous Federal Subsistence Board tyranny, I still enjoyed my hunting experience tremendously.
Alaska truly a Great Land, unfortunately we have knuckleheads administrating access to our Great land.
To Jeremiah Williams, maybe now’s the best time to draft legislation which Senator Sullivan and Representative Begich can introduce to fix this problem.
.
Don’t complain or preach. Stick with facts, examples, and impacts. Be aware people whose outdoor experience is limited to the space between their building and the subway will see your stuff and struggle to make sense of it. Describe the situation briefly, concisely, recommend solutions, talk about cost savings and enforcement efficiencies, package it so as not to annoy non-hunters too much.
.
Put your first draft out to readers for comment, this could work.